"Pranab Mukherji expresses shock at Ganguly's omission from the team."
"Lok Sabha speaker Somnath Chatterjee believes Ganguly was omitted for reasons other than cricket."
"Jagmohan Dalmiya writes to BCCI President citing examples when a player was recalled at the Board President's request."
In the last year and a half, my disillusionment with the media (both
print as well as television) has grown exponentially. This is partly
due to the fact that I was living with someone who was working first
with Balaji and later with Miditech - so her insider views on the
industry made a major contribution to my dislike for it. However, the
major reason for my disgust with the media is the way it attempts to
create news out of no news.
The Ganguly issue - if it is an
issue at all - only strengthens my belief that most Indian news
channels today are simply not worth watching. News channels have been
giving half an hour long reports that show nothing but a few prominent
people from various professions - mostly Bengalis - being 'shocked' and
'stunned' at Ganguly being left out of the team. There were many such
reports but the following are specially noteworthy.
1) Some
middle-aged Bengali movie star claiming on camera that "Had Gavaskar
thrown Ganguly out, I would have accepted it gladly. Had Kapil Dev
thrown Ganguly out, I would have accepted it then too. They are
cricketing greats, and I respect their judgement. But the person who
has thrown him out is Kiran More - just what exactly are his
credentials?"
Oh come on man! What exactly are YOUR
credentials to make that claim? What do you even know about cricket?
The Aussie selection board is full of people who were never really
cricket stars, and they have consistently been providing champions over
the last 15 years, if not more.
2) This one was a classic
example of someone trying weirdo antics to get back into the news after
his unceremonious exit from power: Lalu Prasad Yadav saying on camera
"Sourav apna padosi hai, acha khiladi hai. Usko team se nikaal dena
bilkul galat hai. Desh ke liye usne bahut kuch kiya hai - usko aise
nahi nikalna chahiye."
Well Lalu-ji, I agree with most of
what you said, but whether or not it is right to leave him out of the
team is none of your and mine business. The selection committe must
have had its own reasons, and let us respect those.
3) This
was the most incredible one: Some random MP called Mohan Singh (or
something like that) shouting away to glory in the Parliament talking
about why Ganguly's exclusion from the team is unfair. And to top it
up, he later said on camera that "Ganguly issue has affected millions
of hearts in India. Since Parliament is a mirror of the Indian
citizen's feelings, therefore it is only fair that the Ganguly issue be
discussed in the Parliament."
This was not all. Somnath
Chatterjee, the Lok Sabha speaker, actually agreed to his request! Come
on guys, do we not have enough and more issues to worry about already!?
Or does the Parliament have that much free time - despite Volcker
reports and bomb scares - that it cant find any better topic of
discussion than Ganguly's exclusion.
The new team (i.e. the
one without Ganguly in it) has not played a single match yet, and half
the country is screaming itself hoarse claiming that this team is not
good enough. The politicians, useless as ever, are grabbing this
opportunity to find reasons to be on TV. The more useless the
politician, the more the noise. The movie stars who do not have any
movies or even serials to act in, are utilising their spare time
singing songs about Ganguly and hoping some news channel will have
enough lack of substantial information to air them. Last, but not the
least, a certain section of the general public which is not in the
habit of doing anything constructive is taking this opportunity to show
off their pseudo-leadership skills by going on hunger strikes and
making demonstrations and - in short - doing nothing but wasting their
time through nonsensical activity, and wasting others' time by
disrupting normal life in kolkata. Many of the people in this group
happen to be students who just want to be on TV. In my opinion, the
noise made by these people is nothing but hot air coming out of an
orifice! Let me not elaborate on that.
It is true that the
weirdo antics Indians attempt do not help the situation at hand in any
way. But the insane degree of irresponsibility shown by the news
channels in actually promoting this sort of madness by giving it long
hours of coverage is even more disillusioning. What is even worse is
that very often the news is not even factually correct.
One
such occasion was the July 26th, 2005, when Mumbai was flooded due to
incessant rains. Every single news channel wrote in rudely large-sized
font "Breaking news: Powai dam breaks". What they didn't know was that
Powai doesn't even HAVE a dam!
There was a time when the
Indians' only update was the 8:30pm news bulletin on DD-1. They had
twenty minutes to cover everything useful in the country and the news
was concise, substantial, and worth listening to. Today's news
channels, thanks to their 24-hour availability, have mostly useless
stuff on them and also share this tendency to devote an entire day to a
single news item - be it an item at all or not.
Perhaps it
will take one responsible channel to put the Indian news industry in
some kind of order. Or maybe these channels will continue going
downhill and reach a point of no return and, in the process, leave the
Indian viewer with a completely skewed sense of information. Where
things go from here, only time will tell, but for now I think it makes
a lot more sense to just listen to the headlines from several different
channels and then try to make your own judgement. The news reports and
their conclusions on TV are perhaps best left ignored.